Thermal Hydraulic Safety Analysis

What it is, which accidents it covers, and the reactor codes engineers use to do it

What is thermal hydraulic safety analysis?

Thermal hydraulic safety analysis evaluates how heat transfer, fluid flow and phase change (boiling and condensation) behave in a nuclear reactor under normal operation, operational transients and accidents. Its job is to show that the fuel, the cladding and the reactor coolant system stay within safety limits, and that safety systems remove decay heat when they are called on.

The analysis is done with computer codes that solve the conservation equations for mass, momentum and energy in the coolant, coupled to heat conduction in the fuel and structures and to reactor kinetics. Results support plant licensing (safety analysis reports), plant modifications and power uprates, emergency procedures, probabilistic risk assessment and operator training.

What does the analysis check?

  • Margin to boiling crisis Critical heat flux (CHF) is where boiling stops cooling the rod: departure from nucleate boiling (DNB) in PWRs, dryout in BWRs. Past it, a vapor blanket forms and cladding temperature jumps.
  • Peak cladding temperature For a loss-of-coolant accident in a U.S. light-water reactor, 10 CFR 50.46 limits peak cladding temperature to 2200 °F (1204 °C), cladding oxidation to 17%, and core-wide hydrogen generation to 1%.
  • Two-phase flow and critical flow Break flow rates, flow regimes, phase separation and level swell control how fast inventory is lost and where the water goes.
  • Decay heat removal Emergency core cooling, reflood, natural circulation and passive systems must carry decay heat away long after shutdown.
  • Noncondensable gases Nitrogen from accumulators or hydrogen from cladding oxidation can degrade condensation and natural circulation.
  • Containment response Mass and energy released from the break set containment pressure and temperature, and hydrogen sets the combustion risk.

Which accidents and transients are analysed?

Design basis accidents are the events a plant is designed to withstand with its safety systems. Beyond design basis analysis follows what happens when systems fail, up to core damage and severe accident progression.

Typical events in a thermal hydraulic safety analysis
EventWhat the analysis looks at
Large-break loss-of-coolant accident (LBLOCA) Blowdown, refill and reflood; peak cladding temperature and emergency core cooling performance.
Small-break LOCA (SBLOCA) Slow depressurization, core uncovery and recovery, and the timing of operator actions.
Station blackout (SBO) Loss of all AC power: coping time, natural circulation and passive heat removal.
Anticipated transient without scram (ATWS) Pressure and power response when the reactor fails to shut down on demand.
Main steam line break (MSLB) Overcooling, return to power and containment pressure.
Steam generator tube rupture (SGTR) Primary-to-secondary leakage and the path for radioactive release.
Loss of feedwater and loss of flow Heat-up of the primary system and margin to boiling crisis.
Reactivity insertion Power excursion and fuel enthalpy, usually with coupled kinetics.

Which reactor codes are used for safety analysis?

No single code covers everything. A safety analysis typically combines a system thermal-hydraulic code with codes for fuel, core physics, local flow and, beyond the design basis, severe accidents.

Families of nuclear reactor analysis codes with examples
Code familyWhat it doesExamples
System thermal-hydraulic codes Model the whole plant as connected loops: two-phase flow, heat transfer, pumps, valves and reactor kinetics through transients and accidents. RELAP5/SCDAPSIM and ASYST (ISS), RELAP5-3D (INL), TRACE (U.S. NRC), CATHARE (CEA, France), ATHLET (GRS, Germany)
Severe accident codes Follow an accident past core damage: fuel heat-up and oxidation, hydrogen, melt relocation, lower head failure and fission product release. MELCOR (Sandia National Laboratories for the NRC), MAAP (EPRI); RELAP5/SCDAPSIM and ASYST integrate SCDAP severe accident models with the thermal-hydraulics
Subchannel codes Resolve flow and enthalpy between fuel rods in a bundle to predict local critical heat flux margins. COBRA-TF / CTF, VIPRE
Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) Capture 3-D mixing, thermal stratification and local hot spots that coarse system nodes cannot resolve. General-purpose CFD codes such as ANSYS Fluent, STAR-CCM+ and OpenFOAM
Neutronics and core physics Calculate power distribution and core kinetics; often coupled to a system code for reactivity transients. PARCS, DIF3D, the VERA suite; RELAP5/SCDAPSIM offers optional 3-D nodal kinetics
Fuel performance codes Predict fuel and cladding state (gap, temperatures, fission gas) that sets the initial conditions for a transient. FRAPCON / FRAPTRAN, FuelSim (ISS)
Radiological consequence codes Estimate off-site dose and health consequences from a release. MACCS, RASCAL (U.S. NRC)

The U.S. NRC lists the codes it maintains on its computer codes page.

What is BEPU analysis?

Early licensing analyses stacked conservative assumptions to bound the result. Best Estimate Plus Uncertainty (BEPU) analysis instead uses a best-estimate code and quantifies how uncertain the answer is. A widely used approach is Wilks' method: 59 code runs with sampled input uncertainties give a one-sided 95% probability, 95% confidence bound on a figure of merit such as peak cladding temperature.

ASYST and RELAP5/SCDAPSIM RS4 include Wilks-based uncertainty analysis as standard.

How are the codes validated?

Codes are compared against separate-effects tests, which isolate one phenomenon such as critical flow, CHF or reflood, and integral tests, which reproduce a whole transient in a scaled facility such as LOFT, Semiscale, PKL, LSTF or BETHSY. The OECD Nuclear Energy Agency CSNI validation matrices list the standard test sets, and the IAEA publishes guidance on deterministic safety analysis.

Thermal hydraulic safety analysis software from ISS

Innovative Systems Software develops system thermal-hydraulic codes descended from the SCDAP/RELAP5 code developed at Idaho National Laboratory, with commercial licensing, support and training.

RELAP5/SCDAPSIM

RELAP5 system thermal-hydraulics with integrated SCDAP severe accident modeling for light-water and heavy-water reactors in RS3.4 and RS3.5. RS4.0 and RS4.1 add liquid-metal and molten-salt coolants.

About RELAP5/SCDAPSIM Features by version

ASYST

A best-estimate plus uncertainty system code built on the same physics core. ASYST 4.x adds built-in sodium, lead, lead-bismuth, lithium-lead and molten-salt coolants for advanced reactors.

About ASYST Features by version

Learn thermal hydraulic safety analysis with ISS

Our workshops and training courses teach input deck development, transient analysis and severe accident modeling with RELAP5/SCDAPSIM and ASYST.